Despite the criticisms of some education policy reformers like kevin g. Community discussion guide 3 how to use this guide this guide is designed to be a resource for communities interested in beginning or continuing a conversation about creating and sustaining great schools. A clip from waiting for superman a talk with anthony and his challenges with going to school in washington d. Seventyfive years after he came to life, superman remains one of americas most adored and enduring heroes. Waiting for superman is a 2010 american documentary film directed by davis guggenheim and produced by lesley chilcott. The lives of five harlem and bronx families in the high stakes lottery for access to new york citys best charter schools. While both films come to essentially the same conclusion, i felt that the lottery was an. A call to action to avert a catastrophe in the education of american children, the lottery makes the case that any child can succeed. The title comes from geoffrey canadas own experience of waiting for superman to save him from inadequate schooling. Waiting for superman is yet another book written about our failing schools. An examination of the current state of education in america today.
Education budgets are being cut as states try to balance their fiscal houses, assessment scores of us students are being compared to those of the rest of the world, and the president spoke about education reform in the state of the union. This documentary is about public education in the united states and how it is handle by the goverment. Waiting for superman has helped launch a movement to achieve a real and lasting change through the compelling stories of five unforgettable students. Waiting for superman has helped launch a movement to achieve a real and lasting change through the compelling stories of five unforgettable students such as emily, a silicon valley. Documentary filmmaker davis guggenheim explores the tragic ways in which the american public education system is failing our nations children, and explores the roles that charter schools and education reformers could play in offering hope for the future.
Ravitch notes that waiting for superman is one of a triumverate of recent films, the others being the cartel and the lottery, that have a similar focus. Waiting for superman by davis guggenheim davis guggenheim. Armed with my notepad and accompanied by a fellow teacher, i bought my ticket. The united states spends the more money per capita for education than any other country in the world, yet outcomes continue to fail. Waiting for superman united states proficiency tests youtube. Apr 16, 2016 waiting for superman is moving to say the least. General zod has been waiting for another shot at earth for years, and with 100,000 supermen on his side, it looks like its his war.
The workshop has as an aim for the students to analyze and reflect about the consecuences it has on students to come from a public school. Convention on the rights of the child, we know it cant be distributed by a lottery. Waiting for superman is not available on hulu, but is available for instant streaming to netflix subscribers. Celebrity interview waiting for superman to save our public schools. How davis guggenheims documentary waiting for superman. The story that waiting for superman tells is that emily is desperate to escape her district public high school, woodside high, because shes a bright student who doesnt test well, and due to.
Rentals include 30 days to start watching this video and 48 hours to finish once started. Since many charter schools are not large enough to accept all of their applicants, the selection of students is done by lottery. Part one clearly recaps the issues raised in the film featuring essays. Thats when we come back as we dive into the issues presented in waiting for superman. This is waiting for superman the lottery by bettyann martin on vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them. However, its prospects for a wide expansion are limited, since it is a documentary. Best of superman from graphic novels to nonfiction to paperbacks to childrens books, superman is everywhere, and deserves his own best of list. Sackler got to know the nature of that coalition intimately. Each head of household draws a slip, and the family with the marked slip will lose a member to stoning by the townsfolk. In waiting for superman, a scene isnt what it seems nyt.
This page lists prices for the first 100 issues of superman s appearances in his solo series, which began in 1939. Just try and avoid books where he only makes a cameo. The field of education is receiving a lot of attention right now. Most comic fans know that superman actually began life in action comics. Ravitch on waiting for superman diane ravitchs blog. In waiting for superman, families are cruelly paraded in front of the cameras as they wait for an admission lottery in an auditorium where the winners names are pulled from a hat and read aloud, while the losing families trudge out in tears with cameras looming in their faces in what amounts to family and child abuse.
Of course, some of these families do not win in the lottery, so the film is a tearjerker. What are the main takeaways from waiting for superman. The participant guide is a tiein anthology that develops the films themes in three parts. Mine struggle between being prepared for college and actually attending. In the final scene of the film, the effect of incorporating the results of each lottery and the ultimate fate of each child really puts into perspective the harsh reality of. There are educational success stories and these have been duplicated the kipp academies stand out, for example but it will take a common will at the local level to initiate change. In illinois, where one in 57 doctors loses his medical license and one in 97 lawyers loses his law license, only one in. Although this book was published in 2010, there has been no real change with the problems in our educational system. Read all lottery books you want for free lottery post. Posts about waiting for superman written by whatifconcepts. Sure, education reform was the phrase on the tip of everyones tongue, but after a year most of the fervor and commitment to educational. Authors include such wellknown names in educational policy as diane ravitch author of the death and. Now larry tye, the prizewinning journalist and new york times bestselling author of satchel, has written the first fullfledged history not just of the man of steel but of the creators, designers, owners, and performers who made him the icon he is today.
Waiting for superman is a wakeup call to parents, educators and anyone who cares about the future of the country. The documentary waiting for superman won the audience award at sundance and sent ripples through the world of education. With charles adam, charles adams, jonathan alter, robert balfanz. You wake up every morning and you know that 46,000 kids are counting on you. I admire canadas work with lower income families in nyc, but i think the moral is not as straightforward as this documentary makes it. While one of the students in the film wins a lottery spot at the charter of her choice and has a rigorous, engaging, and bright future. His film was an eye opening, to many, look at the failings of the u. Waiting for superman exposes grim reality that many children face. An interview with director davis guggenheim by hannah goodwyn producer. The most influential scene during this segment is when one of the students, bianca, and her mother, nakia, wait for biancas name to be called as the lottery nears the end. Waiting for superman in the race to nowhere tending our kids education is a hard task. One is the lottery that is played out in the gymnasiums of the schools, with numbered pingpong balls and kids who make your heart ache. On the one hand, seen in light of canadas childhood story, the superhero is a powerful image, embodying hope for rescue. Its notable as a critique of the public school system from the left side of the political spectrum.
And finally, waiting for superman a film opening this week that highlights the national education problem and gives an overview of how charter schools are filling the void left by inadequate public. For many people, these arguments require a willing suspension of disbelief. Lucky for me, i live a short distance away from the one theater where waiting for superman is currently playing in michigan. For parents, teachers, and concerned citizens alike, waiting for superman is an essential guide to the issues, challenges. Instead, it was arranged and filmed by guggenheim after the lottery had already. One of the most pressing issues that waiting for superman engages with is the issue of school choice, and how charter schools with lotteries. A cartel, the lottery, and waiting for superman theblaze. So i happily watched the documentary and quickly whipped out a first draft rough rough draft without even really having to think about it the words. Anthony in the film waiting for superman, we meet anthony, a student who lives in washington, d. In waiting for superman, the father of three examines the sad status of public schools through the eyes.
Oct 05, 2010 neas waiting for superman resources a barrelchested comic book character must save public education. Waiting for superman is an inspiring call for reform and includes special chapters that provide resources, ideas, and handson suggestions for improving. The cartel, the lottery, waiting for superman available. Waiting for superman is a gripping story about the state of public school systems in america, told through the eyes of five hopeful students. In waiting for superman and the lottery, the heroes are charter school. About four minutes into the film, the director davis guggenheim explains that the problem with the american educational system is that we have a variety of schools that are considered as bad, and very few. Waiting for superman in the race to nowhere half moon bay. You can find out values of action issues by clicking here. The storyline the superman books have been building to since 2008 has arrived. Reaction paper on waiting for superman essay example. The 58yearold educator and president of the harlem childrens zone, a. Waiting for superman is filled with disturbing statistics.
Luthor reflects on the deal he made with neron and how. It follows the experiences of several young students in new york city while also narrating this decades surge toward charter schools as an alternative to the nations failing public education system. Documentarian davis guggenheim is most known for an inconvenient truth, his oscarwinning film about climate change. The winners of these lotteries will attend a highfunctioning, wellresourced. An audible gasp was heard at a recent screening when the numbers flashed on screen about one such lottery. The book begins where the film endsa lottery that decides a childs future is indicative of a deeply flawed and unacceptable system that needs to change. Waiting for superman this weekend i finally watched davis guggenheims waiting for superman and can now compare it to madeleine sacklers the lottery another recent documentary bemoaning the wretched state of public education. By building on the themes raised in waiting for superman, we hope it will enable a broad crosssection of. Finding superman goodreads meet your next favorite book. Geoffrey canada born january, 1952 is an american educator, social activist and author. Superman is an interesting choice for the framing metaphor of this film. They may describe discipline problems, where teachers spent as much time.
The lottery echoes the main story line of waiting for superman. New marvel comic features charter school lottery with his application to a charter school, the new spiderman, miles morales, really is a 21st century teen. This initiative serves a 97block area of harlem replete with atrisk children. Waiting for superman documentary analysis educ 300. The film was directed by academy awardwinner davis guggenheim for an inconvenient truth, a man who shows a knack here for weaving ordinarilybland statistics and bureaucratspeak into a riveting drama replete with empathetic victims, altruistic heroes. Students responses to this question will vary, and some may be very personal. Sep 14, 2010 waiting for superman offers powerful insights from some of those at the leading edge of educational innovation, including bill and melinda gates, michelle rhee, geoffrey canada, and more. The filmmakers made sure to film how nakia becomes increasingly more anxious and concerned as time passes during the lottery, but fewer spots become available and her daughters name has not been called guggenheim. From the academy awardwinning director of an inconvenient truth comes the groundbreaking feature film that provides an engaging and inspiring look at public education in the united states. The first chapter is a story about an old guy who noticed a long line of people waiting to buy lottery tickets at a store on the californianevada.
The myth of charter schools diane ravitch on waiting. In waiting for superman, a scene isnt what it seems. At the end spoiler, a little boy gets the phone call that reveals hes been let into the school he wanted, and the cameras just happen to be there, on a random afternoon weeks after the lottery, and the phone line just happens to be tapped so we can hear both sides of the conversation the lady telling the boy hes in and. Since 1990, canada has been president of the harlem childrens zone in harlem, new york, an organization that states its goal is to increase high school and college graduation rates among students in harlem. Waiting for superman comes on the heels of other moving documentaries on the plight of american education, including let me rise, the lottery, the. Apr 16, 2017 waiting for superman sheds light on the variety of problem parents, educators, administrators, and children face with education today. Fighting back the trial of superman, part 8 of 12, script by roger stern, pencils by tom grummett, inks by brett breeding. Each of the kids was sympathetic, and they dramatized the deep inequality of opportunity in america.
Waiting for superman and the lottery anonymous plus, a film about middleupper class parents who would have gone private but for the newer hot charters, watching that group battle it out over stokes or cap city and sitting on multiple waitlist spots is a lot less compelling subject matter than the bigger issue of ailing public. It consists of nine critical responses from various experts in the field of educational reform based on the authors reactions to the documentary entitled waiting for superman. From a tragic beginning to humanitys champion and protector, this tribute to the man of steel features 192 pages of the greatest superman images and. Waiting for superman has helped launch a movement to achieve a real and lasting change through the compelling stories of five unforgettable students such as emily, a silicon valley eighthgrader who is. If we understand education as a civil right, even a human right as defined by the u. Waiting for superman acknowledges, in passing, that only about one in five charter schools is much better than normal public schools and never mentions that more than a third of charter schools are notably worse but the focus on successful charter schools creates the impression that charter schools have the answers.
The lottery follows four families in new york city who enter a charter school lottery to try and solve the problem of failing public education. Waiting for supermans geoffrey canada, president of. Rhetorical analysis of the film, waiting for superman. He never knew his mother, and after losing his father to drugs in 2004, he started to act out in class. Superman and mope remain on the trail of the person who involved mope in criminal activity, while back on the tribunal world cyborg vows to track down superman. I read this book as part of an assignment for a class on public policy in education for my masters degree program. Cover pencils by tom grummett, inks by brett breeding.
Who gets in and who does not is decided on camera by lottery. Waiting for superman in waiting for superman, director davis guggenheim explores how americas public school system is failing students and their families, resulting in tens of thousands of dropouts, while also contributing to the phenomena of failing neighbourhoods. Davis guggenheims documentary about our failing publiceducation system waiting for superman. I also rented the lottery from netflix, another documentary promoting charter schools virtually identical to guggenheims. Waiting for superman offers powerful insights from some of those at the leading edge of educational innovation, including bill and melinda gates, michelle rhee, geoffrey canada, and more. Its highly emotional ending focuses on a drawing or lottery to select which students will be admitted. Now we have waiting for superman, which just might be the best of the genres bumper crop. Nov 02, 2010 that wasnt the only scene that was staged in superman. Students may describe overcrowding, where students compete for a desk or one of too few issued texts. They may describe discipline problems, where teachers spent as. This workshop is for students who have seen the documentary waiting for superman. Although hes a good student now and studies hard, anthony wasnt always at the top of the class. There were days where i thought ill never get this, and the minute you think youre onto something, something else contradicts it.
I had heard of waiting for superman, but had never really had the chance to watch it. Superman has never faced such a difficult challenge how can he stop the two worlds he loves from destroying each other. The filmmakers made sure to film how nakia becomes increasingly more anxious and concerned as time passes during the lottery, but fewer spots become available and her daughters name has not been called guggenheim 1. Waiting for superman is an inspiring call for reform and includes special chapters that provide resources, ideas, and handson suggestions for improving the schools in your own community as well as throughout the nation. Kahlenberg, director davis guggenheim engages the viewer with the personal experiences of charismatic driven students and their struggling parents, who go to great lengths to try and give their children the best education they can.
Waiting for superman responses to preparing for the film 1. Recently i viewed the documentary, waiting for superman, for the umpteenth time, and i noted that almost 5 years after the films september 24, 2010 u. Ravitch is the author of a book titled the death and life of the great. The 12 most frustrating things i saw or didnt see watching waiting for superman. The topic of it is something that i am extremely passionate about and was eager to learn more about.
The film, which argues that charter schoolschoice can be the way out for many students, won the audience award at the 2010 sundance film festival. Produced by a major studio paramount, waiting for superman was released. Sep 27, 2010 waiting for superman glorifies lotteries for admission to highly selective and subsidized charter schools as evidence of the need for more of them. Each is eager to get an education, but in a system riddled with ineffective teachers, staggering dropout rates and schools that are literally falling apart, the odds are more than stacked against them. Nov 02, 2010 i decided to go see waiting for superman, mostly out of an obligation to get up to speed on the charter school controversy. Compelling soundbite to sell a movie maybe but when it comes to real education reform, nea president dennis van roekel gives the american public more credit than the backers of waiting for superman. While lottery officials privately owned management fill their coffers with 50 percent of the take most poor people gamble their savings and their food money tryint to hit the lottery. Shirley jacksons classic the lottery portrays a small town that gathers to hold its yearly lottery, a barbaric game of chance. In waiting for superman, a scene isnt what it seems the. And waiting for superman does present some of the stark inequities in u. Waiting for superman is a paean to reformers like washington, d. Watch the clip titled anthony for the film waiting for superman 2010.
306 1078 858 14 1458 1226 1190 689 1632 46 1150 1645 50 139 742 453 1576 1505 1538 1395 1497 873 1324 1607 710 987 607 876 1203 885 585 1294 1225 1306 481 381 428